The Franchise Anxiety Playbook — Part 3: Red Flags vs. Normal Jitters

How to actually run a validation call — and how to tell the difference between your nerves talking and your gut talking

By the time most prospective franchisees get to validation calls — the point in the process where the franchisor hands you a list of current and former owners to talk to — the anxiety has usually shifted shape. It’s no longer “should I even be considering this,” it’s “what am I supposed to be listening for, and what if I miss something.”

That’s a fair fear. Validation calls are short, the franchisee on the other end is usually being polite to a stranger, and it’s genuinely hard to separate “this person sounds a little guarded because they’re busy” from “this person sounds a little guarded because something’s wrong.” Part 1 drew the distinction between fear of the unknown and fear of a real red flag — validation calls are where that distinction gets tested in real time.

What a Validation Call Is Actually For

Franchisors provide a franchisee list because most states require it, and because a well-run system isn’t afraid of it. Your job on these calls isn’t to get someone to say “buy this franchise” — no franchisee will hand you that decision, and you shouldn’t want them to. Your job is narrower: does this person’s lived experience match what the franchisor told you?

That reframe alone takes a lot of pressure off. You’re not conducting an interrogation. You’re just comparing notes.

Normal Jitters (Don’t Read Too Much Into These)

• A franchisee sounds busy or slightly rushed. They’re running a business. A five-minute call that feels a little clipped isn’t automatically evasive.
• They can’t remember exact numbers off the top of their head. Most owners aren’t sitting on their P&L during a phone call. Vague-but-plausible answers about revenue ranges are normal; ask if they’re open to a follow-up if you need specifics.
• They say it’s “harder than they expected.” Almost every franchisee says some version of this. Owning a business is harder than being an employee — that’s not a red flag, that’s honesty.
• Mixed feelings. A franchisee who’s candid about both the upsides and the grind is usually more trustworthy, not less, than one who’s uniformly glowing.

Actual Red Flags (Worth Slowing Down For)

• The franchisor “helped” set up the call, or a specific person keeps coming up as who to talk to. Item 20 lists are supposed to be the full roster, not a curated highlight reel. Ask for the full list yourself and pick your own names.
• Franchisee numbers don’t line up with the FDD. If several franchisees describe revenue meaningfully below Item 19’s range, that’s a pattern worth investigating.
• Reluctance to discuss why other units closed or transferred. One closure with a clear reason (retirement, relocation) is normal. Discomfort around a pattern of closures is not.
• “Everyone struggles at first, don’t worry about it” as a blanket answer to every specific question. A consistent redirect away from specifics is worth noting.
• You can’t get the full Item 20 list, or it’s unusually short for the system’s size. One of the more serious ones — can signal turnover the franchisor would rather you not connect.

The Practical Way to Run These Calls

• Call more than 3–4 people — aim for at least 6–8, mixing newer owners and 3+ year owners.
• Ask the same core questions on every call: What did year one actually look like financially vs. expectations? What do you wish you’d known before signing? Would you buy this franchise again?
• Pay attention to what’s consistent across calls, not any single comment. One skeptical franchisee isn’t a red flag; five people independently raising the same issue is a pattern.
• Write notes down right after each call — anxiety tends to blur six calls into one vague “feeling” if you don’t.

The Point of This Exercise

Validation calls exist to convert your anxiety into evidence, one way or another. Either outcome — fear meaningfully lowered, or fear meaningfully (and specifically) raised — is progress. The only bad outcome is skipping the calls because making them feels anxiety-inducing in itself.

Next in the Series

Part 4: talking to a skeptical spouse or partner about the decision.

Explore current franchise opportunities and franchisee resources on FranchisePressReleases.com →

Part of The Franchise Anxiety Playbook series, published on FranchisePressReleases.com.